Contravention of children’s orders: Federal Magistrates Court
Tuesday September 8, 2009

Contravention of children’s orders: Federal Magistrates Court

Tuesday, September 08, 2009

Federal Magistrate Altobelli recently summarised the postion of “reasonable excuse” in the Federal Magistrates Court case of Chilton and Chilton for those who breach children’s orders.

The child lived with the mother and had been ordered to have time with the father. The issue was whether the mother had a reasonable excuse in contravening the orders.

Altobelli FM held that the mother did not have a reasonable excuse, stating:

The authorities make it quite clear that there was a clear obligation cast on
the mother to take reasonable steps to deliver the child in accordance with the
order: Stavros & Stavros (1984) FLC 91-562. The orders created positive obligations on her, requiring a genuine commitment to compliance, which is inconsistent with allowing the child to make his own decision about whether or not to have contact with his father: O’Brien & O’Brien [1992] FamCA 52; (1993) FLC 92-396. The respondent mother cannot claim that she sincerely believes that the order was contrary to the welfare of [X] as a reasonable excuse for contravening the order: Gaunt & Gaunt (1978) FLC 90-468.

Stephen Page, Harrington Family Lawyers, Brisbane spage@harringtonfamilylawyers.com 61(7) 3221 9544
Request an Appointment
Fill in the form below to find out if you have a claim.
Request an Appointment - Stephen Page
Things to Read, Watch & Listen
Parental Leave and Surrogacy: A Guide for Australia

Parental leave surrogacy: what surrogates and parents can claim

Parental leave is one of those practical issues that can be overlooked in the excitement and complexity of a surrogacy arrangement. Yet it matters enormously. Time away from work is needed for the birth, recovery, bonding, medical appointments, travel and the first intense weeks of caring for a newborn. For surrogates, intended parents and a… Read More »Parental leave surrogacy: what surrogates and parents can claim

Relocating with Children: Australian Family Law Guide

Relocating with children: what Australian family law requires

Relocating after separation can be an entirely understandable decision. A parent may have a new job, family support, a new relationship, financial pressures or a desire to make a fresh start. But when children are involved, moving a considerable distance can have serious family law consequences. A relocation is not simply about where one parent… Read More »Relocating with children: what Australian family law requires

Australian Citizenship by Descent: Surrogacy Proof Guide

Australian citizenship surrogacy: Home Affairs wants more proof

Australian intended parents pursuing surrogacy overseas need to be ready for a growing paperwork burden when applying for Australian citizenship by descent. A birth certificate alone may no longer be enough. Recent applications indicate that the Department of Home Affairs is increasingly asking for detailed evidence of the surrogate’s pregnancy and birth records, alongside evidence… Read More »Australian citizenship surrogacy: Home Affairs wants more proof

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board