Family Court: “agreement” not enough to say that husband owned property

Family Court: “agreement” not enough to say that husband owned property

In the recent Family Court case of Webb and French, the court had to deal with a “coulda, shoulda, woulda” type case. These are the types of cases where something:

  • could have happened to make the parties richer,
  • should have happened,
  • and if only but for intervening events, would have happened-

but in fact the passage of events meant that they never happened.

The wife alleged that there was an agreement between the husband and his father before the father’s death, whereby the father stated that the motel would be sold and the proceeds split, with the husband to receive a fair amount.

The difficulties for the wife, as identified by Justice Moore, were:

  • there was scarce documentation- the only document that might have verified an “agreement” was an email.
  • the husband’s father died- and his shares in the family entities passed to the husband’s mother.
  • nothing suggested that the husband’s mother knew anything of the agreement
  • the husband’s interest in the motel, aside from running it at a pittance, was as a shareholder in a lessee company.
  • the motel had in recent years run at a loss. Its real value was in the land holding.
  • the husband’s mother had lent money to the lessee company and the family company (which she owned) to keep both afloat.
  • the lessee company was liquidated. There was nothing that suggested that this was untoward.
  • a nil value was attributed to the shares previously held by the husband.

Not surprisingly, the wife was unsuccessful on this point.

Things to Read, Watch & Listen

Embracing Wellness in Your Daily Routine for Fertility

American guest author Ashley Taylor has written an interest article about having a holistic approach to maintaining your health and addressing fertility issues: In the journey toward maintaining your health and addressing fertility issues, embracing a holistic approach is key. Wellness is more than just a goal; it’s a sustainable lifestyle that intertwines various aspects… Read More »Embracing Wellness in Your Daily Routine for Fertility

Consultation open: Queensland Assisted reproductive technology industry

The Regulation of Assisted Reproductive Technology Services Consultation Paper is now available and open for feedback until 25 February 2024. This follows the Minister for Health, Mental Health and Ambulance Services and Minister for Women’s commitment to regulate the assisted reproductive technology (ART) industry in Queensland by 2024. The paper is designed to help inform considerations for regulating… Read More »Consultation open: Queensland Assisted reproductive technology industry

Honouring Excellence in the Legal Profession: Queensland Law Society President’s Medal

The Queensland Law Society (QLS) President’s Medal holds significant prestige within the legal profession as it recognises exceptional solicitors who have made remarkable contributions to their field and the community. Last year, the Director of Page Provan, Stephen Page, was bestowed with this esteemed award, which is carefully judged on service to the community, legal… Read More »Honouring Excellence in the Legal Profession: Queensland Law Society President’s Medal

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board