Family Court case: keep it short and to the point

Family Court case: keep it short and to the point

In the recent Full Court of the Family Court case of Dylan and Dylan, appeals were made about both property and children’s matters.

The Full Court judgment is most significant because of its beginning, which is this shot across the bows of trial judges:

Some sublime articulations of legal principles and of the philosophies and policies underpinning them appear in cases in which the expression was not strictly necessary to the disposition of the particular cause. However, usually, the statements were closely connected with the essential legal points in the case and were made by appellate courts, with a responsibility for development and explication of the law.

A trial judge’s primary function is to decide the case before the court and explain the result, but from time to time a trial judge too might go beyond that task and do so to the great benefit of the law. However, a trial judge embarking upon discussion superfluous to the discharge of the primary role may provoke an appeal, based on the proposition that the irrelevant considerations may have influenced the final result.
That is one of the arguments in this appeal.

If such a judgment is to survive, the appeal court may well need to find that the discussion could not possibly be connected to the result. That finding may provoke the thought that the discussion in the trial judgment might have been better placed in a law journal.

Request an Appointment
Fill in the form below to find out if you have a claim.
Request an Appointment - Stephen Page
Things to Read, Watch & Listen

Known sperm donor: can they claim parental rights?

A known sperm donor can make the path to parenthood feel more personal and familiar. However, knowing the donor does not necessarily make the legal position straightforward. Can that donor later be recognised as a parent? The answer is maybe. Australian law distinguishes between different circumstances of conception, including donation through an IVF clinic, home… Read More »Known sperm donor: can they claim parental rights?

Is a sperm donor a legal parent in Australia?

A sperm donor is not necessarily a legal parent in Australia. Equally, describing a man as a “donor” does not automatically mean he cannot be one. The answer depends on how conception occurs and, particularly with a known donor, the understanding behind the arrangement and what happens after the child is born. That distinction matters… Read More »Is a sperm donor a legal parent in Australia?

Paid sperm donation in Australia: is it legal?

Sperm donors in Australia cannot be paid a fee for their donation. They can, however, be reimbursed for reasonable out-of-pocket expenses. That distinction is the starting point for understanding what is lawful and what could amount to a criminal offence. Australian sperm donation must be altruistic. A donor can help someone have a child without… Read More »Paid sperm donation in Australia: is it legal?

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board