High Court gives special leave in relocation case

High Court gives special leave in relocation case

Justices Hayne and Kiefel have given special leave to the mother to appeal to the High Court against the refusal of the Full Court of the Family Court to overturn a decision of Federal Magistrate Coker which provided that she and the father were to have equal time of their daughter. Federal Magistrate Coker’s decision was to reject the mother’s application to return to Sydney with the child. The result was that the mother was unable to work and lived in Mt Isa in a caravan.

Caroline Overington in the Australian was particularly critical of the earlier decisions.

Special leave is required to appeal to the High Court: appeals are not a matter of right. Special leave is rarely given.

Justice Hayne commented that the case seemed to be one of general application as to what was meant by “reasonable practicability” contained in s.65DAA(5) of the Family Law Act, the section that deals with shared care. His Honour commented:

But a complaint made in this matter is that the Act required consideration of
reasonable practicability in circumstances where the parents of the child,
putting it as neutrally as I can, appeared likely to be living at a distance,
and reasonable practicability then injects questions about, does that mean
somebody has to move, or does it mean nobody has to move? Where does all that
take us? It seems at least at first blush to present issues of a kind that this
Court should look at…

Justice Hayne stated that the mother’s case at first dealt with “reasonable practicality” and:

There are then some related issues about what might be called the process of
assessment, namely whether best interests is a matter to be considered separately from reasonable practicability, whether best interests are matters that fall within section 60CC(3)(m), any other fact or circumstance, but the central issue that [the wife] would seek to tender is this issue concerning the application of reasonable practicability.

His Honour further stated in response to the counsel for the father:

I suspect, but do not know, that that comes close to a central part of the
argument that is advanced against you, that practicability does encompass such
issues [ that the wife has to remain in Mt Isa and is on welfare] and that
it is that kind of issue which is presented by the legislation.

The mother argued that s.65DAA(1)(b), which required a consideration of whether spending equal time was reasonably practical, was a mandatory provision, which the Federal Magistrate was required but did not adequately consider.

Request an Appointment
Fill in the form below to find out if you have a claim.
Request an Appointment - Stephen Page
Things to Read, Watch & Listen

How I Became a Fertility and Surrogacy Lawyer

A legal career that began in mainstream family law evolved into one of Australia’s most specialist practices in fertility, surrogacy and assisted reproductive technology. Over almost four decades, Stephen Page has handled thousands of complex matters, influenced law reform, advised clinics, taught ethics and regulation, and championed the human rights of everyone affected by assisted… Read More »How I Became a Fertility and Surrogacy Lawyer

Lessons From My Own Surrogacy Journey

Stephen Page’s story is a frank, sometimes brutal, ultimately hopeful account of what it means to pursue parenthood when the path is anything but straightforward. From a childhood conviction to be a dad, to confronting infertility, miscarriage, an ectopic pregnancy and the legal uncertainty around parentage, his journey illustrates the medical, emotional and legal hurdles… Read More »Lessons From My Own Surrogacy Journey

Australian Surrogacy Law: Setting the Record Straight on Misleading Claims

Response to op-ed in The Australian by Stephen Page On Wednesday, a UK writer and anti-surrogacy advocate wrote an op-ed in The Australian. I first became aware of the article when my colleague Sarah Jefford OAM told me. For some reason, the author conflated transmen giving birth with surrogacy ( I am still missing the… Read More »Australian Surrogacy Law: Setting the Record Straight on Misleading Claims

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board