Kidney divorce: a donated kidney is not property

Kidney divorce: a donated kidney is not property

I posted sometime ago about the bizarre case of Dr Richard Batista and Dawnell Batista from New York, in which Dr Batista sought that the kidney that he had donated to his dying wife some years ago be considered to be property, and that he wanted US$1.5 million for it, and if he could not get the US$1.5 million, he wanted the theoretical return of the kidney. He had an expert value the donation of the kidney, and also note that his donation was a 1 in 700,000 chance, which saved Dawnell’s life.

Dr Batista’s claim, seen by legal experts as not having a prayer of success, and being without merit and vindictive, was rejected by the court.

“At its core, the defendant’s claim inappropriately equates human organs with commodities,” Suffolk County Court-Attorney Referee Jeffrey Grob declared in a 10-page ruling[PDF file] .

Grob cited state law making it a felony for people to give or take money for a human organ.

“While the term ‘marital property’ is elastic and expansive … its reach, in this court’s view, does not stretch into the ethers and embrace … human tissues or organs.”

Request an Appointment
Fill in the form below to find out if you have a claim.
Request an Appointment - Stephen Page
Things to Read, Watch & Listen

Page Provan’s Response to the Draft Global Consensus Statement on Minimal Standards for Surrogacy

Four leading fertility bodies have released a draft set of global surrogacy standards, and Page Provan has made a submission on it. ASPIRE (the Asia Pacific Initiative in Reproduction), ASRM, ESHRE and IFFS have prepared a draft Global Consensus Statement on Minimal Standards for Surrogacy, dated 29 October 2026. It sets out 21 statements to… Read More »Page Provan’s Response to the Draft Global Consensus Statement on Minimal Standards for Surrogacy

Prove a de facto relationship: what evidence counts?

A relationship can be real and significant to both people, yet still become the subject of disagreement after separation. One person may say they were in a de facto relationship. The other may disagree, or accept that a de facto relationship existed but dispute when it began or ended. When that happens, the question becomes… Read More »Prove a de facto relationship: what evidence counts?

Single mum by choice: 4 legal rules to know

Becoming a single mum by choice involves more than choosing a sperm donor and organising treatment. The legal foundations matter too, particularly when the donor is someone the intended mother already knows. The central questions sound straightforward: Who will be the parents? What role will the donor have? What information will the child be able… Read More »Single mum by choice: 4 legal rules to know

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board