Lesbian couple sue doctor for extra baby

Lesbian couple sue doctor for extra baby

A lesbian couple, who have three year old twin daughters, are suing Canberra obstetrician, Dr Robert Armellin, for wrongful birth after he supervised the implantation of two embryos instead of one into the birth mother during an IVF procedure.

The women are suing the doctor for the cost of raising the mistakenly implanted second child. The sum includes funds for private school, medical expenses and lost wages.

The mother claimed that certain aspects of pregnancy were extremely stressful to her – for instance, buying a stroller – due to the fact that she was carrying twins.

The mother’s partner claimed in court that the couple became so overwhelmed with every day childcare issues that they lost their ability to function as a couple.

Dr Amellin has admitted that a mistake was made in implanting two rather one embryos. There is an issue about whether the mother changed her mind about one instead of two at the last moment before the procedure.

There has been some criticism that the mainstream media has focussed on the couple because they are a lesbian couple rather than a married, heterosexual couple.

The last time a couple sued when a child was wrongly born (due to the failure of clips for a tubal ligation) the case was ultimately thrown out of court by the High Court on the basis that it was a joy to have a child and the positive impact their child had on their lives.

Things to Read, Watch & Listen

A Call for National Reform: Stephen Page’s Submission on Surrogacy to the ALRC

Australia’s surrogacy laws remain inconsistent and outdated, varying widely between states and lacking a unified, national approach. In response to the Australian Law Reform Commission’s review, renowned family and fertility lawyer Stephen Page has submitted a detailed and passionate proposal for reform.

What You Need to Know About Separation & Divorce

Contemplating separation or divorce can be one of the most challenging and emotionally taxing experiences in life. If you find yourself at this crossroads, it’s vital to approach the situation with foresight and preparation.

Should You Go to Iran for Surrogacy?

When it comes to surrogacy destinations, Iran is probably not the first country that springs to mind. Yet, surprisingly, Iran’s surrogacy laws share some striking similarities with those of California—a state known for its progressive and clear legal framework on assisted reproduction.

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board