Remember to make offers: NSW case

When property settlement proceedings are under way, most people make offers to settle because: if you can settle a matter, save a bundle on legal fees and get out- you are ahead; if you make an offer and do better than the offer at trial, then you might be able to get an order for… Read More »Custom Single Post Header

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board

Remember to make offers: NSW case

When property settlement proceedings are under way, most people make offers to settle because:

  • if you can settle a matter, save a bundle on legal fees and get out- you are ahead;
  • if you make an offer and do better than the offer at trial, then you might be able to get an order for costs in your favour, which should reduce some of the costs that you would otherwise have to pay.

There is then an incentive both to make offers to settle, and to consider very carefully any offers that are made.

In the recent New South Wales District Court case of Henriques v Fernandez, the court was considering a property settlement application under the Property Relationships Act. The court made an order in favour of the former de facto wife, the plaintiff. District Court Judge Johnstone held:

In this case it is evident that this plaintiff was required to commence these
proceedings to enforce her entitlement in respect of a division of the
assets. It is clear from the evidence before me, and from what I am told
from the bar table, which I accept, that at no time did the defendant
concede any entitlement on the part of this plaintiff to anything. The
evidence to the contrary is overwhelming and for those reasons it is
appropriate that this plaintiff be awarded costs. Indeed, had there been an offer of compromise, or a Calderbank letter I would have awarded indemnity costs. However, there is not.

(emphasis added)

In other words, if the plaintiff had made an offer to settle, she may have received substantially more in costs than she did.

Things to Read, Watch & Listen

Legal Parentage After Domestic Surrogacy Arrangements

Accredited Family Law Specialist and Page Provan Director Stephen Page presented a paper at Growing Families’ National Conference Day Sydney.

Legal Aspects of Donation and Surrogacy in Queensland

On 11 June 2022, Accredited Family Law Specialist and Page Provan Director Stephen Page presented a paper at Monash IVF Qld Clinical Day regarding the legal aspects of donation and surrogacy in Queensland.

The Decline of Inter-Country Adoption

Our Director Stephen Page was honoured to be interviewed by London family lawyer Yasmin Khan-Gunns about her proposed essay on the decline of inter-country adoptions.