Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander intended parents considering surrogacy

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander intended parents considering surrogacy

Yesterday the High Court in Love v Commonwealth decided by a 4: 3 majority that Aboriginal (and necessarily Torres Strait Islander people) if they were not citizens under the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 were nevertheless allowed to live in Australia and could not be deported.

The case arose concerning two men, Mr Love and Mr Thoms who were in immigration detention. The Government was seeking to deport each of them. Both were born outside Australia. Both claimed they were Aboriginal. The Court accepted that Mr Thoms was Aboriginal, but did not decide the issue concerning Mr Love- leaving the Federal Court to review the evidence and come to the decision about whether or not he was Aboriginal. In essence if the Federal Court after further review of the evidence found that Mr Love is Aboriginal, he can stay; if not, he will have to go.

The case has implications for surrogacy practice. Where intended parents live outside Australia, and undertake surrogacy outside Australia (such as the US or Canada) and identify as Aboriginals or Torres Strait Islanders, their children may be able to live in Australia because of their special status.

If anyone is considering taking advantage of the High Court decision, then they ought to get expert legal advice first. It is clear that the lengthy High Court decision has lots of bells and whistles. Each of the four member majority had their own reasons for reaching that decision- and not all views match up.

Things to Read, Watch & Listen

Surrogacy and Medicare: Why the Outdated Exclusion Needs to Go

In this episode of the Australian Family and Fertility Law Podcast, Stephen Page dives into a long-overdue issue: the exclusion of surrogacy from Medicare funding in Australia.

Importing Sperm into Australia. Where Does it Come From?

In this eye-opening video, Stephen Page breaks down the surprising reality behind sperm donation in Australia — and why we rely so heavily on imports.

Importing Eggs into Australia. Where Do They Come From?

In this video, Page Provan Director, Stephen Page, dives into the egg-sport reality of Australia’s fertility landscape. With a shortage of local egg donors, many Aussie hopefuls are turning overseas to make their dreams of parenthood a reality.

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board