Perils of parenting- Family Court

Perils of parenting- Family Court

In the recent Full Court of the Family Court case of Simpson and Brockmann, the court was faced with what to do about parentage of two children. It appears that there was one sperm donor, with one child being born to Ms Simpson and one to Ms Brockmann.

Ms Simpson and Ms Brockmann had had a trial in the Federal Magistrates Court. An appeal ensued, and on the morning of the appeal, they handed up to the court a proposed order consenting to the appeal and declaring that each of the women be named as the parent of the child of the other.

This issue had not been canvassed at the trial, or at any earlier stage of the appeal process.

Justice Warnick, with whom Justices May and Barry agreed, remitted the matter back to the Federal Magistrates Court for further hearing and rejected the proposed declaration, in part because:

I am not satisfied that the power to make a declaration as to parentage in
that section in fact applies to circumstances that present here, where there is
no issue about the parentage of either of the children. It is well known who the
mother is of each child. It is not known who the donor of sperm was, but it is
known that it was the same male person in each case. Nothing contended to be any
other way.

The issue here is not about parentage, but the position or description
which each of the mother’s wishes to adopt in relation to the child of the other
mother for the purpose of parenting orders. That is not the same as the
determination of an issue about parentage.

Things to Read, Watch & Listen

Embracing Wellness in Your Daily Routine for Fertility

American guest author Ashley Taylor has written an interest article about having a holistic approach to maintaining your health and addressing fertility issues: In the journey toward maintaining your health and addressing fertility issues, embracing a holistic approach is key. Wellness is more than just a goal; it’s a sustainable lifestyle that intertwines various aspects… Read More »Embracing Wellness in Your Daily Routine for Fertility

Consultation open: Queensland Assisted reproductive technology industry

The Regulation of Assisted Reproductive Technology Services Consultation Paper is now available and open for feedback until 25 February 2024. This follows the Minister for Health, Mental Health and Ambulance Services and Minister for Women’s commitment to regulate the assisted reproductive technology (ART) industry in Queensland by 2024. The paper is designed to help inform considerations for regulating… Read More »Consultation open: Queensland Assisted reproductive technology industry

Honouring Excellence in the Legal Profession: Queensland Law Society President’s Medal

The Queensland Law Society (QLS) President’s Medal holds significant prestige within the legal profession as it recognises exceptional solicitors who have made remarkable contributions to their field and the community. Last year, the Director of Page Provan, Stephen Page, was bestowed with this esteemed award, which is carefully judged on service to the community, legal… Read More »Honouring Excellence in the Legal Profession: Queensland Law Society President’s Medal

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board