Tasmanian surrogacy reform may be “years” away

Tasmanian surrogacy reform may be “years” away

According to the head of the Tasmanian Upper House committee handling the issue, it may be “years” before Tasmania comes up with adequate surrogacy laws, as reported by the Mercury:  http://ow.ly/6eZO8.

This would be a mistake. Despite my repeated criticisms of the failure of Australian governments to have a one size fits all surrogacy law, on the obvious basis that for example intending parents in Western Australia are unique or different, or have peculiar Western Australian characteristics as compared to those in the eastern States, which therefore justifies discrimination in Western Australia against gays and lesbians and single men, to continue the ban in Tasmania against surrogacy would be a mistake.

All it will do is to ensure that Tasmanians either go interstate or overseas for treatment or have a traditional surrogacy and not tell anyone about it. It is legal for Tasmanians to get treatment in some other States, and it is legal for Tasmanians to go overseas for commercial surrogacy. Or if this is all too much trouble, Tasmanian intended parents will simply up and leave, and vote with their feet, moving interstate to somewhere where it is easier to undertake surrogacy.

Tasmania cannot afford to lose these people. The clients I have helped who want to proceed with surrogacy are people in their 30’s and 40’s, often in the professions or small business, and with enough money to proceed with a surrogacy. As an altruistic surrogacy costs $40-60,000 and overseas surrogacy costs range from $40,000 to $120,000, those contemplating these sizable costs are the very people that Tasmania should be striving to keep living in Tasmania for the benefit of its economy.

All I would ask the politicians in Tasmania to do is to legislate, and quickly, to ensure that Tasmanians are not left out.

Things to Read, Watch & Listen

How to Obtain a NSW Parentage Order for a Child Born Overseas

Starting July 1, 2025, groundbreaking changes to New South Wales law will significantly affect families involved in overseas surrogacy arrangements. These changes empower the NSW Supreme Court to issue parentage orders for children born through commercial surrogacy overseas—a legal pathway previously unavailable.

Monash IVF Mixup Prompts Health Ministers Rapid Review of IVF Regulation

In recent months, Australia’s fertility sector has been shaken by two unprecedented embryo mixups at Monash IVF clinics. These incidents have not only caused distress and confusion for affected families but have also exposed critical weaknesses in the country’s IVF regulatory framework.

Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) Human Tissue Review

Explore the Australian Law Reform Commission’s review on human tissue laws and what it means for IVF, surrogacy, and reproductive medicine. Learn about key legal changes and their implications for families and practitioners.

Family Law Section Law Council of Australia Award
Member of Queensland law society
Family law Practitioners Association
International Academy of Family Lawyers - IAFL
Mediator Standards Board